Hire us

Made by humans.Talk to one →

How to brief an agency after a bad agency experience

September 29th 2026

By Emily

If you’ve been burned by an agency before, you’re not being difficult by going into the next pitch a little guarded. You’re being sensible. A convoluted process, a brief that got quietly reinterpreted along the way, work that only ever seemed to reach the people who weren’t actually making the decision. These things leave a mark. The good news is that almost all of it is avoidable, and almost all of it shows up early if you know what to ask.

Here’s what’s actually worth putting to a new agency in a pitch, why each question matters, and what a genuinely good answer tends to sound like.

Ask who you’ll actually be working with, day to day

Start here, because it matters more than almost anything else. Ask who’ll be on the account once the contract’s signed, how senior they are, and how much of their week is genuinely set aside for your work. A confident agency answers this without flinching. They’ll tell you exactly who, and exactly how much time, because they’ve already thought about it: a strategist and a designer full-time for the opening weeks, say, easing to a lighter touch once things are in build. That kind of precision is a gift. It means someone has already planned your project properly, rather than hoping the charm of the pitch team will carry it through to delivery.

Ask what decisions actually get measured against

This is the one that catches people out most, because it’s invisible from the outside. Ask what the work gets judged against once it lands on someone’s desk. Not who signs it off, what it’s actually held up to. A team without a clear strategy underneath the work ends up deciding by taste, or by whoever’s most senior in the room that day, and that’s a slow, wobbly way to make anything. A team that’s done the strategic thinking properly has something firmer to point to: an agreed positioning, a defined audience, a specific problem the work is meant to solve. When a decision needs making, they’re not guessing at what you’ll like. They’re checking it against what you both already agreed the brand needs to do.

A team without strategy underneath will often mediate disagreement on decisions through opinion, which usually means whoever’s more senior, or louder, wins. A team with a clear strategic foundation can do something better: point back to the thing you both signed off earlier and ask which direction actually serves it. That’s the entire reason strategy gets built before design starts.

Ask what happens when the brief needs to change

Briefs shift. That’s not a failure of planning, it’s just what real projects do once they meet the real world. What separates a good agency from a painful one is what happens in that exact moment. Ask directly: if we add something meaningful halfway through, how and when do we hear about what it costs and what it delays? A confident answer sounds like a process, something they can point to and say “this is exactly what happened last time it came up.” A vaguer answer, something closer to “we’ll figure it out as we go,” is worth pressing gently. It sounds generous in the room. It rarely feels generous on the invoice.

Ask for a straight opinion on your timeline

Here’s a small test with a big payoff. Ask what they’d change about your brief or your deadline if they were being completely honest with you, right now, before anything’s signed. A team planning to do the work properly will have an answer, maybe a phase they’d sequence differently, or a milestone that quietly worries them. Total agreement with everything you’ve proposed feels wonderful in a pitch. It’s rarely a sign of a team that’s actually thought it through, and it’s almost never a sign of a team who’ll tell you the truth later, when the truth is less convenient.

Ask to see the mess, not just the highlight reel

Every agency will show you their best work, lit beautifully and edited to a tidy three-act structure. Ask instead about the project that didn’t go to plan. What actually happened, and what changed because of it. Listen for specifics rather than a smoothed-over anecdote with the edges filed off. A team that can talk plainly about a stakeholder relationship that got difficult, or a first direction that missed entirely, is showing you something far more useful than a case study ever could: that they know how to course correct when something isn’t landing. That is precisely the skill you’re paying for, because very few projects go perfectly on the first pass.

Ask what a normal week actually looks like

Skip past the kick off meeting and the final presentation for a moment. Ask what week three or four actually feels like. How often you’ll hear from the team, what a status update genuinely contains, how quickly questions get answered between scheduled calls. A lot of agency disappointment has nothing to do with the final output. It’s the quiet stretch in the middle where nobody’s quite sure what’s actually happening with something they’re paying for. If they can show you a real example of a weekly update from a live project, even better. It tells you far more than a polished template ever could.

Ask how they handle the moment you don’t love it

One more worth putting on the list: what happens when you genuinely don’t like the work. A team that’s good at this can usually describe their revision process with real precision, how many rounds are built in, what happens if you’re still not happy after those, and how they tell the difference between “this doesn’t answer the brief” feedback and “I just don’t personally love it” feedback. That distinction is way more important than it sounds. A team that’s thought about it has probably learned the hard way why it’s worth having an answer ready.

Finding a confident agency

These aren’t trick questions, and a confident branding agency won’t treat them that way. They’re simply the questions that let both sides find out early whether this is going to work, which is exactly what a good pitch process is for. If a previous agency left you cautious going into the next one, use that caution to ask better questions, rather than to write off the whole process.

Ask us any of these questions today.


Looking for a London branding agency?

About KOTA

KOTA is a global branding agency and creative web design studio based in london. Our brand-to-build approach brings strategy, identity, creative web design, development and growth marketing into one connected process. We help ambitious businesses find brand clarity, turn it into creatively confident work and build digital systems that create commercial momentum.

Related Projects

Interested in working with KOTA?

Drop us a line at
hello@kota.co.uk

We are a Creative Digital Agency based in Clerkenwell London, specialising in Creative Web Design, Web Development, Branding and Digital Marketing.